Financial markets gladly welcomed the deal, done at Brussels on Thursday morning. In fact, in light of what would happen if all attempts to reach agreement ended in complete failure, the fact that European leaders have found common ground at least for some items, no matter how blurred were no details of the agreement and how it would be untenable neither was the result, of course, is a positive development.But is it worth to take a step back to see the whole picture: a complete failure the dominant economic doctrine, which caused great damage to both Europe and the USA.The doctrine in question rests on the assertion that in the post-crisis circumstances, banks must be saved, and the society should pay for it. The crisis caused by the decrease of state intervention in the economy, causes an even greater shift vpravo.Massovaya unemployment rather than to stimulate job creation, it becomes an excuse for the introduction of austerity measures - cutting public spending and social programs.In order to convince us of the correctness of this doctrine, we were told that no alternatives that help banks and spending cuts needed to stabilize financial markets, the budgetary savings that it actually creates new jobs. The idea was that spending cuts will give confidence to consumers and businesses, and this confidence is supposed to stimulate private spending, thereby offsetting the negative effects of government spending limits.Some economists do not believe it. One sarcastic critic spoke of tough measures aimed at increasing ekonomichesokgo growth as a belief in "the magic of self-confidence." That was me.Nevertheless, this doctrine has been extremely influential. The idea of austerity for the sake of economic growth, in particular, advocated by Republicans in Congress and the European Central Bank, who last year persuaded the governments of all European countries, including those that have not experienced financial difficulties to engage in "fiscal consolidation".And last year when David Cameron became prime minister of Great Britain, he immediately began to implement a program of spending cuts, believing that it will contribute to economic growth - a decision that was taken by American pundits with an ingratiating approval.Now, however, the results are obvious. Picture is deplorable. Due to austerity measures Greece is sinking deeper into the quagmire of economic crisis and this recession, which has arisen not from a lack of effort by the Greek government, last week was the cause of a secret report to European leaders that the existing program does not work. The British economy is stalling under the influence of austerity measures, and the confidence of consumers and businesses has plummeted, not increased.Perhaps the most striking fact is the failure of this policy - that is what is now considered a success story. Several months ago, various experts have begun to extol the achievements of Latvia, which, after the terrible recession could, however, reduce the budget deficit and to convince the market that is financially stable. This is indeed an impressive achievement, however, was achieved at the cost of 16% unemployment and the economy at least, and finally growing, is still 18% below pre-crisis level.Thus, to save the banks and also to punish employees for their mistakes - it's not a recipe prosperity. Was there an alternative? Yes. That's why I'm in Iceland, taking part in a conference on the country that chose a different path.If you watch the news bulletins of the financial crisis and have seen his superb kinotraktovki such as "internal matter» (Inside Job), then you know that Iceland should become an example of economic disaster. Escaped bankers left the country with huge debts and seemingly in a hopeless situation.However, the path to economic Armageddon funny thing happened: the very despair of making it impossible to habitual behavior, giving the freedom to break the rules. When all the banks and saved the company was forced to pay, Iceland has allowed banks to go bankrupt, and has expanded the social safety net. When all fixated on how to appease foreign investors, Iceland has imposed temporary restrictions on capital movements, to give yourself room to maneuver.And what is happening in Iceland? The country has not escaped the great economic loss or substantial decline in living standards. However, it could limit the growth of unemployment and the suffering of the most vulnerable segments of society. Social safety net has survived, as well as a system of social obligations to the citizens. "Could be worse," perhaps not the most optimistic slogan, but when everyone is expecting a crushing catastrophe, such an outcome can be considered almost a triumph.And therein lies a lesson for everyone else: the suffering of our citizens are not a necessity. And if people are going through times of incredible trials and faced with increasingly stringent government measures, it is not an objective necessity, and the result is a completely informed choice. Everything can be changed.
Sunday, August 12, 2012
Paul Krugman. Iceland: the path that was not selected
Financial markets gladly welcomed the deal, done at Brussels on Thursday morning. In fact, in light of what would happen if all attempts to reach agreement ended in complete failure, the fact that European leaders have found common ground at least for some items, no matter how blurred were no details of the agreement and how it would be untenable neither was the result, of course, is a positive development.But is it worth to take a step back to see the whole picture: a complete failure the dominant economic doctrine, which caused great damage to both Europe and the USA.The doctrine in question rests on the assertion that in the post-crisis circumstances, banks must be saved, and the society should pay for it. The crisis caused by the decrease of state intervention in the economy, causes an even greater shift vpravo.Massovaya unemployment rather than to stimulate job creation, it becomes an excuse for the introduction of austerity measures - cutting public spending and social programs.In order to convince us of the correctness of this doctrine, we were told that no alternatives that help banks and spending cuts needed to stabilize financial markets, the budgetary savings that it actually creates new jobs. The idea was that spending cuts will give confidence to consumers and businesses, and this confidence is supposed to stimulate private spending, thereby offsetting the negative effects of government spending limits.Some economists do not believe it. One sarcastic critic spoke of tough measures aimed at increasing ekonomichesokgo growth as a belief in "the magic of self-confidence." That was me.Nevertheless, this doctrine has been extremely influential. The idea of austerity for the sake of economic growth, in particular, advocated by Republicans in Congress and the European Central Bank, who last year persuaded the governments of all European countries, including those that have not experienced financial difficulties to engage in "fiscal consolidation".And last year when David Cameron became prime minister of Great Britain, he immediately began to implement a program of spending cuts, believing that it will contribute to economic growth - a decision that was taken by American pundits with an ingratiating approval.Now, however, the results are obvious. Picture is deplorable. Due to austerity measures Greece is sinking deeper into the quagmire of economic crisis and this recession, which has arisen not from a lack of effort by the Greek government, last week was the cause of a secret report to European leaders that the existing program does not work. The British economy is stalling under the influence of austerity measures, and the confidence of consumers and businesses has plummeted, not increased.Perhaps the most striking fact is the failure of this policy - that is what is now considered a success story. Several months ago, various experts have begun to extol the achievements of Latvia, which, after the terrible recession could, however, reduce the budget deficit and to convince the market that is financially stable. This is indeed an impressive achievement, however, was achieved at the cost of 16% unemployment and the economy at least, and finally growing, is still 18% below pre-crisis level.Thus, to save the banks and also to punish employees for their mistakes - it's not a recipe prosperity. Was there an alternative? Yes. That's why I'm in Iceland, taking part in a conference on the country that chose a different path.If you watch the news bulletins of the financial crisis and have seen his superb kinotraktovki such as "internal matter» (Inside Job), then you know that Iceland should become an example of economic disaster. Escaped bankers left the country with huge debts and seemingly in a hopeless situation.However, the path to economic Armageddon funny thing happened: the very despair of making it impossible to habitual behavior, giving the freedom to break the rules. When all the banks and saved the company was forced to pay, Iceland has allowed banks to go bankrupt, and has expanded the social safety net. When all fixated on how to appease foreign investors, Iceland has imposed temporary restrictions on capital movements, to give yourself room to maneuver.And what is happening in Iceland? The country has not escaped the great economic loss or substantial decline in living standards. However, it could limit the growth of unemployment and the suffering of the most vulnerable segments of society. Social safety net has survived, as well as a system of social obligations to the citizens. "Could be worse," perhaps not the most optimistic slogan, but when everyone is expecting a crushing catastrophe, such an outcome can be considered almost a triumph.And therein lies a lesson for everyone else: the suffering of our citizens are not a necessity. And if people are going through times of incredible trials and faced with increasingly stringent government measures, it is not an objective necessity, and the result is a completely informed choice. Everything can be changed.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment