Saturday, August 11, 2012

Accounting Fair Value in financial crisis


As is well known among professionals related to the fair value of an ambiguous - there are both supporters and opponents of the concept. The financial crisis that began in 2008, intensified the debate about fair value. In the western periodicals in the second half of 2008 some observers call the fair value of the causes of the financial crisis as a result of the collapse of financial markets, the holders of impaired financial assets carried at fair value, they were forced to cancel hundreds of millions of dollars in profits. This has weakened the financial statements, resulting in a loss, reduced reserves increased risks, and ultimately reduced the value of companies, which resulted in series of bankruptcies. As a result, the fair value exacerbated the already difficult situation.
In these circumstances, companies that consider undervalued the value of their financial instruments, offer to suspend the rules of fair value and allow the use of internal estimates of the true future value of their assets or the value at which assets were acquired. It is assumed that this measure will support the balance sheets and will facilitate the financial crisis. In other words, it is proposed to abandon fair value, and return to the historical estimates or rely on subjective assessments of management.

In 2008, the Financial Stability Forum published a report with recommendations to improve the situation in financial markets. The report was the result of international cooperation (including the IASB) and key national institutions of financial centers.

Reference:

The Financial Stability Forum was established in 1999 at the initiative of the Group of Seven heads of financial departments (G7 Ministers and Governors) to promote international financial stability. Forum brings together representatives of national financial authorities (central banks, supervisory authorities, finance ministries), international financial institutions, international regulatory and supervisory authorities.
Two of the 67 recommendations proposed by the Forum are related to the estimated fair value:

A. Estimates of fair value in illiquid markets: The IASB should improve its guidance on valuation of financial instruments, in the case when markets are no longer active.

Two. Disclosure: The IASB should improve its standards to achieve better disclosure of information about assessments, methodologies, and uncertainties associated with estimates.

In response to these recommendations, the IASB amended IFRS 7 "Financial Instruments - Disclosures", which allow, in certain situations to previously forbidden transfer of financial assets from one category to another (from fair value to amortized cost), and prepared draft for discussion on improving disclosures about fair value of financial instruments in financial statements.

Securities Commission of the United States informed the company that in their reports, they can use their own judgment to determine the fair value of assets. Council of Financial Accounting Standards (FAS U.S.) issued guidance on the appropriate fair value accounting in illiquid markets.

However, this study has shown the Western periodicals, even amid the financial crisis, standard setters, regulators, investors and auditors support the fair value and transparency of information it provides.

Robert Herz, chairman of the FASB, in its report (Herz R. Lessons Learned, Relearned, and Relearned Again from the Global Financial Crisis - Accounting and Beyond. 08 December, 2008), answering the question to what extent the use of fair value impact on the financial crisis, gives the following fact: "From January to October 2008 was closed 17 banks, with assets of these banks are carried at fair value, representing only 10% of total assets. Before the crisis, investors believed that the value of banks' overemphasized. Not surprisingly, financial investors and analysts say that the problem is, by contrast, is the lack of banks use of fair value. "

Partner at PwC Boris Eten and chairman of the National Council for Accounting France Jean Babble note: "Valuation of financial instruments at fair value, accompanied by appropriate disclosure provides investors better understand current market conditions. Waiver of the fair value will throw ten years ago, progress in financial reporting »(Lepeti J., Eteni B., Marteau D. How to Arrive at Fair Value During a Crisis. 28 July, 2008.)

Members of the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) argue that "for all the current problems of increasing the transparency of IFRS and fair value is still the best of the available models. We must not forget that the estimate of costs has led to stagnation and lack of transparency in the economy of the Asia-Pacific region in 1997-1998., Which ultimately contributed to the development of international accounting standards »(ACCA. Climbing out of the Credit Crunch. September, 2008).

An analysis of the situation in the development of the concept of fair value to the following conclusions:

A. The use of a full fair value for financial reporting - a new phenomenon, but to reflect the fair value of securities used for a long time. Therefore, even if the opponents do not agree with the concept of taking full account of the fair value adjustment of financial assets on the rising and falling markets, and accounting for results in profits over the period of the century have been successfully used in practice.

Two. The financial crisis is new is that the markets have ceased to be active, so the assessment has to do with the use of models and disclose in the financial statements additional information about the used models. However, according to standards developers, even these estimates provide a more relevant and reliable information than the alternative, does not take into account the current economic conditions (such as lack of liquidity).

1 comment:

  1. Great post. I’m trying for blogs on relevant topics but, very less resource with blog commenting option. This material is quite a bit different in that the information is up to date.


    Fair Value Accounting

    ReplyDelete